Inventing in software

To invent, you need a good imagination and a pile of junk.

— Thomas Edison

This is what is so facinating about programming. Your “pile of junk” consists of digital assest instead of physical matterial, so the raw materials are not limited by the normal laws of supply and demand. In software, you are limited only by your imagination.

Does Size Matter to Search Engines

Yahoo and Google are trying to one up each other on whose database contains more pages. Does it really matter? Isn’t relevancy more important? It depends on who your user is.

If most of your queries on search engines return hundreds or thousands of results, then it probably doesn’t matter who has the biggest index. As long as Google and Yahoo get the popular pages, you’ll most likely find what you are looking for. If you get a bunch of results from your search you are probably aren’t looking for a specific document on the web, so it doesn’t matter which page you get as long as it has the information you are after.

Most internet users fall in the above category. I tend to find that many of my searches return less than 20 results and sometimes only 2 or 3 or even 0. For people like me the number of pages searched is much more important. In fact for those types of searches the method used to order the results (determine the relevancy) isn’t really important. With a small number of pages, it is easy to scan through the list and find the most relevant entry.

Today I was working on a piece of equipment and it started giving me a less than helpful error message. I typed the manufacturer (in quotes) and the error message (also in quotes) into Google hoping to find out how to fix my problem. There were zero results. I tried it on Yahoo and got the same thing. After poking around in some forums I was able to find a post that described the problem on a page that was missing from both Yahoo and Google’s databases. The post contained all the phrases that I had searched for it just wasn’t in either of the search engine’s indexes.

Five years ago I taught a community college class about the internet. I used Geocities to put up the tests, class outline, etc. Today I tried search for:
site:geocities "juco internet class"
In Google I get zero results. With Yahoo I get a single result that links to the page I was searching for.

I’m sure that there are other items that I could find with Google that won’t show up in Yahoo. I’m not trying to say one engine is better than the other. The point is that the index size does matter if you are looking for a specific document. If Yahoo decides that they are going to maintain a larger index than Google, then there are going to be pages that can be found in the Yahoo index, but not in Google’s. If you are looking for one of these pages then size is very important.

Backing Up Subversion Automatically

Subversion is great, but like any data repository, it must be backed up regularly. Many people have tried to implement version control without really understanding how it works, only to later discover that their backup strategy wasn’t working.

The svn backup script I use is run every night as part of a cron job. Each morning I get an email telling me if everything went ok or not. Here is a list of what I want to happen with each backup:

  1. Dump all the data out of the repository
  2. Name the file with a timedate stamp in the filename. Something like YYYYMMDD-HHMM will work.
  3. gzip the file to save space
  4. Move a copy of the file to another server using scp

Seems pretty basic, but when I’m doing a backup by hand, I like to go a step further and verify the backup by creating a new repository, filling it with the backed up data and then checking it out. This lets me verify that my backup works and that I can get my code back if necessary. So for this verification stage I want to do the following:

  1. Pull the zipped file back down from the remote server
  2. Unzip it.
  3. Create a new repository
  4. Load all of my content into the new repository
  5. Checkout a copy of trunk into a directory
  6. Cleanup

The following perl script accomplishes everything I need in a svn backup script. When it is run with cron, I get a short email everyday telling me that it completed. The output is intentionally terse. If I get a long email I know something went wrong, but I don’t have to wade through a bunch of logging information if everything went as planned. If you want more output, take the -q off of the Subversion commands. The emails that cron sends me look like this if nothing went wrong:

Dumping Subversion repo /var/svn to my_backup-20050921-0100...
Backing up through revision 340...

Compressing dump file...

Created /home/admin/backups/my_backup-20050921-0100.gz

my_backup-20050921-0100.gz transfered to my.server.com

---------------------------------------
Testing Backup
---------------------------------------
Downloading my_backup-20050921-0100.gz from my.server.com
Unzipping my_backup-20050921-0100.gz
Creating test repository
Loading repository
Checking out repository
Cleaning up

If you want to use this on Windows, you’ll need to make a few changes. First the way we generate the time and datestamp for the file name will need changed. You’ll probably want to use something other than scp and gzip as well.

Here is the script. I hope some people find it useful.

my $svn_repo = "/var/svn";
my $bkup_dir = "/home/backup_user/backups";
my $bkup_file = "my_backup-";
my $tmp_dir = "/home/backup_user/tmp";
my $bkup_svr = "my.backup.com";
my $bkup_svr_login = "backup";

$bkup_file = $bkup_file . `date +%Y%m%d-%H%M`;
chomp $bkup_file;
my $youngest = `svnlook youngest $svn_repo`;
chomp $youngest;

my $dump_command = "svnadmin  -q dump $svn_repo > $bkup_dir/$bkup_file ";
print "\nDumping Subversion repo $svn_repo to $bkup_file...\n";
print `$dump_command`;
print "Backing up through revision $youngest... \n";
print "\nCompressing dump file...\n";
print `gzip -9 $bkup_dir/$bkup_file\n`;
chomp $bkup_file;
my $zipped_file = $bkup_dir . "/" . $bkup_file . ".gz";
print "\nCreated $zipped_file\n";
print `scp $zipped_file $bkup_svr_login\@$bkup_svr:/home/backup/`;
print "\n$bkup_file.gz transfered to $bkup_svr\n";

#Test Backup
print "\n---------------------------------------\n";
print "Testing Backup";
print "\n---------------------------------------\n";
print "Downloading $bkup_file.gz from $bkup_svr\n";
print `scp $bkup_svr_login\@$bkup_svr:/home/backup/$bkup_file.gz $tmp_dir/`;
print "Unzipping $bkup_file.gz\n";
print `gunzip $tmp_dir/$bkup_file.gz`;
print "Creating test repository\n";
print `svnadmin create $tmp_dir/test_repo`;
print "Loading repository\n";
print `svnadmin -q load $tmp_dir/test_repo < $tmp_dir/$bkup_file`;
print "Checking out repository\n";
print `svn -q co file://$tmp_dir/test_repo $tmp_dir/test_checkout`;
print "Cleaning up\n";
print `rm -f $tmp_dir/$bkup_file`;
print `rm -rf $tmp_dir/test_checkout`;
print `rm -rf $tmp_dir/test_repo`;

Eric Wilhelm has another subversion backup method that is worth checking out as well. His method is based on dumping out a backup at every X number of commits instead of based on a specific period of time. This has some advantages particularly with large repositories that don’t change very often.

Kathy Sierra has an interesting post on her blog about college. Toward the end she talks about how her teenager has decided not to go to college. Kathy reasons that since her personal career has very little to do with her original degree, her daughter is just as well off to spend her time at a vegetarian cooking school instead of pursuing a 4 year degree.

While Kathy makes some excellent points, I don’t think that the cooking school is going to prepare her daughter as well as attending a university. It doesn’t matter what she studies. That is the whole point of a liberal arts education–you don’t just study your field of interest. Places like that are known as vocational schools.

Go to college and pick something you enjoy studying. You are going to spend 4 years developing yourself as a person. If you think the facts you learn in an accounting class to make you attractive to an employer in 10 to 15 years, you’re going to be very disappointed.

Kathy Sierra has an interesting post on her blog about college. Toward the end she talks about how her teenager has decided not to go to college. Kathy reasons that since her personal career has very little to do with her original degree, her daughter is just as well off to spend her time at a vegetarian cooking school instead of pursuing a 4 year degree.

While Kathy makes some excellent points, I don’t think that the cooking school is going to prepare her daughter as well as attending a university. It doesn’t matter what she studies. That is the whole point of a liberal arts education–you don’t just study your field of interest. Places like that are known as vocational schools.

Go to college and pick something you enjoy studying. You are going to spend 4 years developing yourself as a person. If you think the facts you learn in an accounting class to make you attractive to an employer in 10 to 15 years, you’re going to be very disappointed.