Nightmare Programming Project

Here is a scary scenario for a programmer. Unfortunately it is probably not too uncommon. Imagine you are starting a new job. Before accepting the position you ask all the right questions, but on your first day you discover the following:

  1. The lead programer left two months ago. (You already knew this.) The only form of documentation is a few comments and javadocs. (You didn’t know this.)
  2. While the project has it’s own CVS server, the backups were done without shutting down CVS and they had never been tested. The server crashed and all the backups were corrupt. There is a copy of the source code that someone had on their local hard drive, but no history information and there isn’t code of the last stable release.
  3. The 30% of the unit tests fail. Another 30% have errors. Some of the tests are just wrong, others rely on having resources configured in a specific way. There are also some tests that aren’t actually testing code, but instead do things that populate the databases, etc.
  4. The core framework used in the project is based on a 6 year old proprietary binary library that doesn’t have any documentation.
  5. The bug tracking data was lost in the server crash. Since you don’t have the source code from a stable release, there are a bunch of little bugs, but none of them are documented.

Sound like a nightmare? Definitely. But it is also an opportunity. Here are the steps I would take under the above circumstances. I’d enjoy hearing what others have to say as well.

  1. Implement Version Control. Personally I prefer Subversion, but regardless of what you use, getting it up and running should be your first priority. And just having it functional isn’t adequate. It needs to be running, automatically backing up, and you must test doing a restore from the backup data. If you haven’t tested your backup you are begging disaster to strike. (more on version control)
  2. Setup an Issue Tracker. You need a place to keep track of the problems you find. You don’t want to remember a nasty bug when a customer calls to tell you about it. The issue tracker should be used for more than just bugs. It should be your central repository for everything the developers are working on. That means it should hold features, tasks, ideas for improvements, etc. Set milestones and assign issues to those milestones. If you are tracking estimated time for each issue, you’ll be able to set realistic schedules.
  3. Document your setup. You need to know how to setup the build and run environment from scratch. I would suggest starting with a clean machine and setting everything up. If your project builds fine on the old developer’s machine, but not on any new machines you setup, you have a problem. You may find yourself spending several days hunting down all the dependencies and configuration settings.
  4. Fix the Unit Tests. If tests are failing the developers will ignore them. All of your active tests have to pass every time you run them. If this means you go from 400 tests down to 50 that is fine. Tests that don’t pass can be prefixed with “pending” so they won’t run and you can re-implement them over time. If a test fails you need to consider the build to be broken.
  5. Setup Automatic Builds. This doesn’t need to be anything fancy, but if code compiles and tests fine on your machine, but fails on others, you need to know about it right away. Ideally the code should recompile whenever there are changes in the version control system. Also you should make the build fail if the tests fail. When a build fails, you can have it send email, flash the lights, or turn on the overhead sprinklers, but you should not ignore it.
  6. Document the code. Digging through someone else’s code and trying to make sense of it can be extremely painful. But you really can’t start writing your own code until you understand how the old code works. Even if you want to replace parts of the old code, you will need to understand what the code you plan to replace is actually doing. Make sure you record your findings, so they can benefit others. You may get called away to rescue another troubled project and you want to make sure you successors don’t have to start over.

Technorati Tags: , ,


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *